Sugarwish alternatives: how Their Treat compares
Sugarwish made "let them choose" gifting popular. If you like that idea but want them to mix and match in one box, here's an honest look at how the two compare.
Side by side
Their Treat
$35 · $45 · $65 | 1, 3 or 5 picks
- Yes: Mix & match between snacks, tea, beauty and moreOne box, any combination.
- Yes: Same number of picks in every categoryThe Bigger Treat is always 3 picks: 3 snacks, 3 beauty items, or a mix.
- Yes: Games & card decksIn the Biggest Treat.
- Yes: Free shippingTo the mainland U.S.
- Yes: Your note and a GIF
Sugarwish
Small $39 · up to $139
- No: One category per giftThey pick a category first, then favorites inside it.
- No: Picks change by categoryFewer picks for premium items, e.g. 1 bottle of wine.
- No: Games & card decksNot currently.
- Yes: Free U.S. shipping
- Yes: Your note
What makes Their Treat different
They can mix and match
Each box isn't locked to one category. A recipient can pick a snack, a hand cream and a spice blend, all in the same box.
Every pick counts the same
The number of picks never shrinks because they chose something fancier. Three picks means three items, from any category.
Games and card decks, not just food
Card decks and games for curious minds of every age, in our Biggest Treat. A good fit for people without a sweet tooth.
Made by small businesses
We pick products from small makers, never mass producers.
Questions
Is Their Treat like Sugarwish?
Both let the recipient choose. At Their Treat they can mix categories in one box, every category gets the same number of picks, and the Biggest Treat includes games and card decks.
Can they choose from different categories in the same box?
Yes, in the Bigger and Biggest Treats. The Little Treat (1 pick) covers Snacks, Tea and Spices & Seasonings. The Bigger Treat adds Beauty, and the Biggest Treat adds Beauty and Games & Decks. They can combine any of these.
Does the price include shipping?
Yes. Shipping to the mainland U.S. is free, and the recipient never pays anything.
Do you ship outside the U.S.?
Not right now, but we're exploring ways to expand.
Sugarwish is a trademark of its owner. Their Treat isn't affiliated with Sugarwish. Details come from its public website as of October 2026; check its site for current offers.